invented allowed fiction helped paid published called looked died went was appealed sat photographed buried used played fact returned belonged invented
Greyfriars
Bobby
Posted
by
Peter
on
29
September
2011
Tourists
from
all
over
the
world
come
to
be
beside
the
statue
of
Greyfriars
Bobby
,
outside
Greyfriars
Church
in
Edinburgh
.
In
the
podcast
today
,
we
will
talk
about
"
fact
"
and
"
fiction
"
.
A
"
"
is
something
which
is
true
;
something
which
I
,
or
someone
else
,
can
prove
to
be
true
.
For
instance
,
it
is
a
fact
that
the
earth
is
round
.
And
"
"
is
the
opposite
of
fact
.
It
means
something
which
is
,
something
which
is
made
up
something
which
comes
from
the
imagination
.
In
a
bookshop
,
you
will
find
a
section
"
fiction
"
.
This
is
where
you
can
buy
novels
,
books
of
short
stories
and
so
on
.
Another
section
of
the
bookshop
will
be
called
"
non
-
fiction
"
.
This
is
where
you
can
buy
biographies
,
and
books
about
cooking
or
gardening
,
books
to
help
you
play
golf
better
,
and
books
about
learning
English
.
Now
lets
go
to
Edinbugh
,
the
capital
city
of
Scotland
.
Edinburgh
is
an
old
and
beautiful
city
,
full
of
fascinating
places
to
visit
.
One
of
these
is
a
church
called
Greyfriars
Kirk
.
"
Kirk
"
is
a
Scottish
word
for
"
church
"
.
The
church
is
built
on
land
which
was
once
a
Franciscan
monastery
.
The
Franciscan
monks
wore
grey
clothing
,
hence
the
name
"
Greyfriars
"
.
Greyfriars
Kirk
an
important
part
in
the
history
of
Scotland
in
the
17th
century
,
and
a
centre
for
Protestant
opposition
to
the
king
.
However
,
the
reason
that
thousands
of
people
visit
Greyfriars
Kirk
every
year
has
nothing
to
do
with
17th
century
history
.
No
,
the
visitors
come
to
see
a
little
statue
of
a
dog
,
called
Greyfriars
Bobby
.
Bobby
to
a
man
called
John
Gray
(
or
"
auld
Jock
"
as
he
was
commonly
known
.
)
Auld
Jock
was
a
night
watchman
,
and
Bobby
with
him
everywhere
.
Then
,
in
1858
Auld
Jock
of
tuberculosis
.
He
was
in
the
churchyard
of
Greyfriars
Kirk
.
For
the
next
14
years
,
Bobby
beside
his
master's
grave
waiting
for
him
to
return
,
until
at
last
in
1872
Bobby
himself
died
.
Soon
after
that
,
a
wealthy
lady
for
a
statue
to
commemorate
the
dog
,
and
tourists
have
come
to
visit
the
place
ever
since
.
There
have
been
books
and
a
film
about
Greyfriars
Bobby
,
and
in
Edinburgh
you
can
buy
all
sorts
of
Greyfriars
Bobby
souvenirs
.
Bobby
is
indeed
one
of
the
most
famous
dogs
in
the
world
.
What
do
you
think
about
this
story
?
Perhaps
you
find
the
story
of
Greyfriars
Bobby
very
moving
.
Perhaps
there
are
tears
running
down
your
cheeks
as
you
think
of
the
poor
little
dog
waiting
for
his
master
who
never
.
Or
perhaps
you
are
thinking
,
"
What
a
stupid
dog
!
Why
didn't
he
go
away
and
chase
cats
or
chew
bones
or
do
other
things
that
make
a
dog
happy
?
"
Or
perhaps
you
are
wondering
,
"
Is
the
story
of
Greyfriars
Bobby
true
?
Is
it
fact
or
fiction
?
"
Unfortunately
for
the
tourist
industry
of
Edinburgh
,
there
are
reasons
to
think
that
it
may
be
fiction
.
Jan
Bondeson
of
Cardiff
University
has
recently
a
book
about
Greyfriars
Bobby
.
Jan
thinks
that
Bobby
was
a
stray
dog
and
that
the
man
who
after
the
graveyard
the
story
about
Bobby
sitting
beside
his
master's
grave
.
People
in
19th
century
Britain
were
often
rather
sentimental
,
and
a
stories
like
Greyfriars
Bobby
to
them
.
The
man
who
looked
after
the
churchyard
to
tell
the
story
to
visitors
,
and
the
visitors
would
put
their
hands
in
their
pockets
and
pull
out
a
few
coins
to
give
to
him
.
The
owner
of
a
nearby
restaurant
and
other
local
businessmen
to
spread
the
story
,
in
order
to
encourage
more
visitors
to
come
.
When
the
original
"
Bobby
"
died
(
probably
in
1867
)
,
they
even
found
another
dog
to
take
his
place
.
In
other
words
,
Mr
Bondeson
thinks
that
the
story
of
Greyfriars
Bobby
was
a
publicity
stunt
by
the
Edinburgh
tourist
industry
.
So
,
fact
or
fiction
?
I
cannot
possibly
say
what
I
think
.
Scottish
history
is
full
of
romantic
stories
.
Wealthy
American
tourists
who
imagine
that
they
have
Scottish
ancestors
believe
these
stories
-
all
of
them
.
The
Scottish
tourist
industry
depends
on
them
.
It
is
one
of
the
unwritten
laws
of
our
country
that
English
people
like
me
are
not
to
say
that
a
Scottish
story
,
no
matter
how
implausible
,
is
not
true
.
So
,
if
you
want
to
believe
that
Greyfriars
Bobby
sat
for
14
years
beside
his
master's
grave
,
you
can
believe
it
.
I
am
not
going
to
stop
you
.